Guide · 21 Nov 2026 · Penang
Short stays or long-term rental: which is better?

Rent your unit by the night or by the year? We compare the two side by side, list the pros and cons, and work out one Penang unit both ways.
By Vinn, Real Estate Negotiator REN81915 · General information, not legal or financial advice

The short answer
Neither wins everywhere. On Penang Island the building decides first: ordinary condos can only be let long-term, while short stays need a commercial-title unit in a building that allows them. Where both are possible, only busy, well-run short stays earn more than a long-term tenant; the average listing earns less after costs. Long-term rent is steadier and simpler.
Below: the two side by side, the pros and cons of each, one unit worked out both ways, and how to choose.
Sources: NST (Aug 2026), Bernama (Oct 2026), short-stay market data (Aug 2026).
Side by side: Penang today
With an operator, short stays are almost as hands-off as long-term rent. The real trade-offs are the operator’s share, the contract, and income that moves with the seasons, against a fixed rent and a tenant who stays for a year or more.
| Short stays (with an operator) | Long-term rental | |
|---|---|---|
| Who runs it | An operator: bookings, check-ins, cleaning, guests and pricing. You get a monthly statement. | You or an agent find a tenant; then the rent comes in every month. |
| Who stays | Tourists, families, business visitors and patients’ families, for a few nights | One tenant or family, usually for a year or more |
| What it earns in Penang now | RM24,200–38,500 a year in bookings for an average listing, by area; George Town is highest | Furnished 2-bedroom: RM2,000–4,500 a month in George Town, RM1,500–2,500 in Bayan Lepas |
| Price | About RM280 a night in George Town, about RM500 at Batu Ferringhi; changes with season and events | One fixed rent for the whole term |
| Gross yield | Moves with bookings, month to month | About 3–4% in George Town, 4–5.5% in Bayan Lepas |
| Who takes a cut | The operator: about 20–30% of revenue. One listed operator shares net room revenue 80:20 with owners on a three-year agreement. | The agent: about one month’s rent per tenancy |
| Owner still pays | Usually utilities, internet and the licence (RM900–1,300 a year from 2027) | Little: the tenant usually pays utilities |
| Penang Island rules | Commercial title only, building must allow it, licence for each unit | Works for any condo or serviced apartment |
| Use it yourself | Usually, by blocking dates with the operator | No, not during the tenancy |
| Wear and tear | Faster, though the operator handles cleaning and upkeep | Slower, and the deposit covers damage |
Sources: Short-stay market data, 12 months to July 2026: George Town, Batu Ferringhi, Tanjung Bungah, Bayan Lepas, The Light City (Gelugor area), Penang operator fees (2026), EdgeProp (Aug 2026), iQI, Penang rents and yields (Jul 2026), Bernama (Oct 2026).
Short stays: pros and cons
Best for owners who want the highest possible income, or a holiday home that pays for itself, and are happy to hand it to a good operator.
Pros
- Higher nightly income: a George Town night averages about RM280, far more than a day of monthly rent.
- Flexible prices: charge more for holidays, festivals and big events at the new convention centre.
- Use it yourself: keep dates free for your own holidays or visiting family.
- Hands-off with an operator: bookings, check-ins, cleaning and pricing are done for you; you read a monthly statement.
Cons
- Rules first: on Penang Island, only commercial-title units in buildings that allow short stays qualify, and each needs a council licence.
- Income swings: quiet months and new competition change what you earn.
- The operator’s share: about 20–30% of revenue, and a contract that often runs for a few years.
- Costs that stay with you: usually utilities, internet, the licence and faster wear.

Long-term rental: pros and cons
Best for owners who want a steady monthly income that covers the instalment, with little of their own time.
Pros
- Steady income: the same rent every month, easy to plan your instalments around.
- Little work: one agreement a year, and the tenant usually pays utilities.
- Fewer rules: any condo or serviced apartment can be let long-term, with no licence.
- Less wear: one careful tenant is easier on the unit than a new guest every few days.
Cons
- Lower ceiling: rent is fixed for the term, even when demand rises.
- Empty months: each month between tenants is a month of no income.
- Tenant risk: late rent or damage can take time to sort out.
- No personal use: the unit is not yours to stay in during the tenancy.

The numbers: one unit, two ways
In our example, short stays need about RM54,500 a year in bookings, roughly 190 nights, just to match long-term rent. The average George Town listing took RM38,500, so it keeps less than a long-term tenant would pay. Short stays pull ahead only in the busiest, well-run units.
Our assumptions: a furnished 2-bedroom serviced apartment in George Town
- Long-term: RM3,000 a month, let for 11 months a year, about one month’s rent to an agent. Keeps about RM30,000 a year.
- Short stays: about RM280 a night (George Town average), an operator keeping 20% of bookings, RM80 cleaning per stay (2.5 nights on average), RM400 a month for utilities and internet, the RM1,100 licence for 2 rooms from 2027, and RM1,500 a year for wear and linen.
The line moves with the rent. If the same unit would only let for RM2,500 a month, short stays need about RM47,200 a year in bookings to match it. Keep in mind that the area average includes units of every size, and some listed for only part of the year, so a full-time, well-run 2-bedroom can do better than the average.
For each area’s figures and what is coming to them, see Penang’s best areas for short stays, ranked →
Sources: iQI, furnished George Town 2-bedroom rents (Jul 2026), short-stay market data, 12 months to July 2026: George Town, Batu Ferringhi, Tanjung Bungah, Bayan Lepas, The Light City (Gelugor area), Bernama (Oct 2026). The months let, agent fee, operator share, cleaning, utilities and wear figures are our own estimates; quotes vary. The nightly rate is the George Town average for all unit sizes.
Which one suits you?
Choose by what you want from the unit. The safest pick is a unit that can do both, so you can switch when the market changes.
Short stays suit you if you are looking for
- Hassle-free income: an operator runs everything, and you just read the monthly statement;
- Higher upside: more income in busy months, holidays and big events;
- A holiday home that earns: stay there yourself or host family, and let it earn while you are away;
- Flexibility: no tenant holding the unit for years if you want to sell or move in later.
Long-term rental suits you if you are looking for
- Steady, predictable rent: the same amount every month to cover your instalment;
- The simplest setup: one tenant, one agreement, no licence;
- The widest choice of units: any condo or serviced apartment works;
- Tenants who stay for years: near big employers, schools and campuses.
The best of both
Several new projects in George Town, Tanjung Tokong and The Light City allow short stays and are also built to let well long-term. New buildings near new amenities tend to ask the highest rents, as at The Light City. See Light City rents →
Tell us your budget and how hands-on you want to be, and we’ll shortlist projects that fit.
Ask which projects allow short stays
Sources: NST (Aug 2026), Penang Property Talk (Aug 2026), The Star (Nov 2026). Rules as at 21 Nov 2026; check with the council and the building before you buy.
Frequently asked questions
Is short-term or long-term rental better in Penang?
It depends on the building and how busy the unit is. On Penang Island, ordinary condos can only be let long-term. Where short stays are allowed, our example shows a unit needs about RM54,500 a year in bookings to match long-term rent after costs, while the average George Town listing took RM38,500. Busy, well-run short stays can earn more; long-term rent is steadier and simpler.
Can I rent out my Penang condo for short stays?
Not if it is an ordinary residential condo on Penang Island. Since 1 August 2026, short stays there need a commercial-title unit, such as a serviced apartment or SoHo, in a building whose rules allow it, and each unit needs a council licence.
What does a short-stay licence cost in Penang?
From 1 January 2027, RM500 a unit a year plus a fee by rooms: RM400 for one room, RM600 for two and RM800 for three, so RM900 to RM1,300 a year in total.
Can one unit do both?
Yes, if the building allows short stays. Many owners start with one and switch when the market or their plans change, which is why we suggest picking a unit that suits both.
Ready to look?
Short stays or long-term? Pick a unit that can do both.
Tell us your budget, and we’ll shortlist Penang projects that allow short stays and let well long-term.
Browse all projectsChat with us